Index funds vs ETFs UK is a common question for anyone choosing their first fund, and investment trusts add a third option. All three pool money from many investors into a single portfolio. They differ in how they are structured, how you buy and sell them, and how their price relates to the value of what they hold.
Readers of our guide to robo-advisory services will often find these fund types inside the portfolios those services build. This guide explains what each one is, in plain terms, without ranking or naming any product.
Key Takeaways
- Open-ended funds, which include most UK index funds, grow and shrink as investors join and leave, according to the Association of Investment Companies (AIC).
- ETFs are traded on stock exchanges. The London Stock Exchange says it has over 2,860 listed exchange-traded products, supported by registered market makers.
- Investment trusts are closed-ended, so their share price is set by supply and demand and can sit at a discount or premium to the value of their assets.
- The AIC defines the ongoing charge as a percentage of net asset value covering the regular, recurring costs of running a trust.
- The FCA’s new disclosure regime for consumer investments began its transition on 6 April 2026 and is due to be fully in force on 8 June 2027.
Index Funds vs ETFs UK: The Three Structures Compared
The table below sets out the main differences. “Index fund” here means an open-ended fund, such as a unit trust or open-ended investment company (OEIC), that tracks an index. ETFs can also track an index, so the key difference is structure, not strategy.
| Feature | Index fund (open-ended) | ETF | Investment trust |
|---|---|---|---|
| Structure | Open-ended: units are created or cancelled as money comes in or goes out | Fund listed on a stock exchange | Closed-ended: a listed company with a fixed number of shares in issue |
| How it trades | Bought from and sold back to the fund manager | Bought and sold on an exchange, with market makers supporting liquidity | Shares bought and sold on the stock market |
| Pricing | Based on the value of the fund’s assets (net asset value, NAV) | Market price, which can differ from NAV | Market price set by supply and demand; can trade at a discount or premium to NAV |
| Borrowing | Not permitted for gearing | Set out in each fund’s documents | Can borrow to invest (gearing) |
| Ongoing charges | Shown as an ongoing charges figure (OCF) | Shown as an ongoing charges figure | Shown as an ongoing charge, a percentage of NAV |
| Regulatory status | Regulated fund; FCA disclosure rules apply | Regulated fund admitted to trading on an exchange | Listed company; costs disclosed under FCA rules, which changed in 2024 to 2026 |
How Each Fund Type Trades
Index funds (open-ended)
The AIC describes an open-ended fund as “a collective investment fund which increases and decreases in size as investors enter and leave it.” When investors sell, the manager gives them their cash back, cancelling units if necessary, according to an AIC article from March 2023. Because managers must be able to meet redemptions at any time, the AIC notes these funds are often limited to investing in liquid assets.
ETFs
ETFs trade on a stock exchange like shares, so their price can move during the trading day. The London Stock Exchange says it lists over 2,860 exchange-traded products from more than 90 issuers, with liquidity “supported by a broad network of registered market makers”. The page does not give a date for these figures. In the index funds vs ETFs UK comparison, this exchange listing is the main practical difference: you trade an ETF through a broker at the market price, rather than dealing with the fund manager.
Investment trusts
Investment trusts are companies whose shares are listed on the stock market. Because they are closed-ended, with a fixed number of shares, their price “depends on demand for and supply of those shares on the stock market”, according to the AIC. The AIC also notes that investment companies can take on gearing, meaning borrowing to invest, which “is off-limits to open-ended funds”. Gearing can increase gains when markets rise and increase losses when they fall.
Premiums and Discounts Explained
Net asset value (NAV) is the value of a fund’s investments, minus any liabilities, divided by the number of shares or units. According to the AIC, an investment trust trades at a discount when its share price undervalues its assets, and at a premium when the price overvalues them.
Hypothetical example. Trust A has a NAV of 100p per share.
- If its shares trade at 90p, the discount is (100p minus 90p) ÷ 100p = 10%.
- If its shares trade at 105p, the premium is (105p minus 100p) ÷ 100p = 5%.
A buyer at a 10% discount pays 90p for 100p of underlying assets. That gain is only realised if the discount narrows, and a discount can also widen. The AIC reported that the typical stock-market-focused investment company traded at a discount of just over 5% at the end of the year referred to in its commentary. It notes that averages had been in single figures for several years, compared with 10% to 20% or more in earlier decades. The commentary is undated, so this figure is not independently confirmed for 2026.
Ongoing Charges Explained
MoneyHelper says the ongoing charges figure (OCF) “takes into account the annual management charge (AMC) and all the expenses of running the fund”. The AIC defines the ongoing charge for investment trusts as “a measure, expressed as a percentage of NAV, of the regular, recurring costs of running an investment trust”.
Hypothetical example. On a £10,000 holding:
- An ongoing charge of 0.20% costs £10,000 × 0.20% = £20 a year.
- An ongoing charge of 1.00% costs £10,000 × 1.00% = £100 a year.
These charges come out of the fund’s value, not as a separate bill. Platform fees and dealing costs are extra, and MoneyHelper notes that fees “won’t always be easy to spot”. Comparing charges is part of any index funds vs ETFs UK decision, but charges alone do not show what a fund invests in or how it is run.
Regulatory Status and Protection
How costs are disclosed is changing. In September 2024, the FCA allowed listed closed-ended investment funds to depart from certain PRIIPs and MiFID cost disclosure requirements. Under its policy statement PS25/20, the FCA’s new Consumer Composite Investments regime began its optional transition on 6 April 2026 and is due to be fully in force on 8 June 2027. It introduces a “product summary” with standardised content on costs, risk, return and past performance.
Regulation does not protect against market losses. MoneyHelper notes that you get no compensation if your investments fall in value. Whichever structure you hold, the value of the investments can go down as well as up.
All three fund types can be held in a stocks and shares ISA, which affects how returns are taxed but not how the funds behave.
Disclaimer
Precise Investors is a financial news and information site. We are not a registered investment adviser, and nothing in this article is personalised financial advice. Markets move, and this article reflects conditions at the time it was published. Do your own research, and consider speaking with a licensed financial adviser before making investment decisions. Read more about Precise Investors.
Final Thoughts
The index funds vs ETFs UK question is mostly about structure. Open-ended index funds deal directly with the manager, ETFs trade on an exchange at a market price, and investment trusts are listed companies whose shares can trade away from the value of their assets and can use borrowing.
Each structure has different trading, pricing and cost features, and none is suitable for every investor. Charges, liquidity and how closely price tracks value are all worth checking in a fund’s own documents. For more on UK investing, browse our Stocks & Shares coverage.
Data Sources
- Open-ended funds and ongoing charge definitions: Association of Investment Companies, Glossary
- Investment trust pricing and gearing: Association of Investment Companies, Sister, sister, March 2023
- Discounts and premiums: Association of Investment Companies, Discounts: challenge or opportunity?
- ETP trading on the London market: London Stock Exchange, Trading Exchange Traded Products
- Consumer Composite Investments regime: FCA, PS25/20
- 2024 investment trust cost disclosure forbearance: FCA statement, September 2024
- Ongoing charges figure: MoneyHelper, Types of investments
- No compensation for falls in value: MoneyHelper, Stocks and shares ISAs
Last reviewed: [DATE TO BE ADDED BY EDITOR]


Comments (0)
Average Rating: No ratings yet/5 (0 reviews)
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!